knowing myself

 

Oscar Wilde Be yourself, everyone else is alre...

Oscar Wilde Be yourself, everyone else is already taken up (Photo credit: symphony of love)

 

I was out running yesterday around my local park. It’s beautiful there. The weather was cooler – but just right for me and running in.

 

As I started my second lap, I saw a small child – about three years old and their caregiver. The child had no coat on, and long sleeves and trousers and seemed quite content – my running app tells me it was 18 degrees. But what caught my attention was the caregiver’s insistence that ‘you need to put a coat on. It’s cold and everyone else has one’. The child insisted they were not cold and the caregiver insisted it was cold and so the child needed to put a coat on.

 

Even at my slow speed, I was past this little dyad before I saw the end of that play out, but I imagine that not many three year olds win that battle. And it made me sad. For me, it’s a prime, and very basic example of Rogers’ organismic valuing process (our valuing system). The child is being told that its valuing process is incorrect (MUST be cold) and then (assuming this pattern continues throughout life) learns that many other things that it thinks are somehow ALSO ‘incorrect’. And before you know it, we have clients in our therapy rooms who don’t know who they are or what they feel, or what they like and need.

 

As trainees also – we are confronted with a LOT of things as trainees – from spending days (by the end of training) with each other in group process, trying to manage the way we feel in response to several people’s feels. Yet, when you are told something as basic as ‘You are cold’ and you do not think you ARE cold, how can you trust in yourself for the big decisions, when you ‘know’ you were wrong about the small ones? This follows on to our ‘experiential learning’ also – in may places throughout our training, we are experiencing things that are very different to what we have experienced in our lives so far. In my family, you didn’t talk about how you felt. That’s not going to get me far in counselling training (or in therapy). So in training I am constantly looking at theory, at conversations, and trying to ‘get at’ my feelings around these things, as well as trying to make academic theory make sense, so I am doing ‘double duty’ here (as I suspect, many people are).

 

But this not TALKING about feelings then often leads to not having them, because what’s the point of having a feeling if you can’t talk about it? – if as a small child, you are alone with that feeling, both good and bad. There is a difficulty then as an adult, when people say to you that as you use language like ‘gut feeling’ that you MUST then be having a feeling. In my case, it doesn’t SEEM like a feeling, it seems like knowledge, but just as the small child who was told they were cold, when they did not feel they were, I am told I have a feeling, when I do not feel like I do. I accept that other people in my position might experience this as a feeling, but at the same time, I think that I need to do much more work in my own therapy before I can get to that stage for myself. Unlike that child, I can choose to reject the assertion, and know that their experience of those words is just that, and mine is mine. After all, Rogers – proposition two: The organism reacts to the field as it is experienced and perceived. This perceptual field is “reality” for the individual. I think I just reached a new level of personal acceptance there.

 

“The curious paradox is that when I accept myself just as I am, then I can change”

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “knowing myself

  1. lifeandptsd says:

    I am not sure I understand your view on the coat issue. Where is the line between bringing our children up to teach them what we know (“it’s cold outside sweetie and if you want to stay at the park, you need to put your coat on so your body stays warm”) and allowing them to run free (“you don’t want to wear a coat? Fine by me!”)? Should we force them to eat healthy for their own benefit? What if they want chocolate at every meal? Kids do not have the critical thinking to make wise choices, so where is the line?

    • Hi 🙂 my point isn’t that we shouldn’t have boundaries. If the caregiver wants the child to wear a coat that is fine. But they made the child wear the coat by denying the child their own experience. It wasn’t (objectively) cold, so it’s entirely possible that the child was warm. Telling the child they are cold teaches the child they don’t know their body.

      I have absolutely no problem with either of your scenarios, or even ‘I have your coat here, please come out it on when you are cold’, but I think that in telling us we are wrong about how we feel, adults help to create children who don’t understand themselves.

      I hope this helps.

  2. dpnoble says:

    Hi, I really enjoyed reading this and the rest of your blog. I got here from the “community” pages – so yes, they work! Your article is quite thought provoking, while – as the previous commenter notes – we clearly have to pass on our own learned experiences to our children, like you I do believe that we have to set limits so that we don’t stifle emerging personalities and self determination. As any parent knows one of the most over used word by a toddler (usually around 2-3 years old) is “no” – at that age they are suddenly realising that they have a voice and can express a choice – albeit it’s usually “no” at that age. As parents we have to balance that, I lost count of the Humber of times that my children went out wearing something that wasn’t all that practical, just because they didn’t want to wear what I had picked out for them – as long as there were no harmful consequences I always let them. But of course with children it is about setting boundaries, we can’t let them do what they want, wear what they want, irrespective of circumstances. So that’s a long winded way of saying I support your notion that we should support our children in making decisions, allowing them to assert their own individualism. I think I could write a whole lot more on that, but that will do for now. Now, for your blog, as I said I enjoyed reading this and other articles, however I was left wanting to know more about you – as far as I can see you are an anonymous blogger – given your profession that’s perhaps understandable, but maybe there is some way you can share a little more insight about you, why are you training to be a therapist, what is your background, what has motivated you to blog? I look forward to reading more from you, whether you remain anonymous or not. Good luck!

  3. dpnoble says:

    Happy to have provided you with some writers stimulus! We all need that from time to time.

Say something about this

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s